|
|
New Member: Harshavardhan Devadiga, India
| Join Now! |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
| | Shirady repairs no takers- NH in a fix |
 | |
|
|
| By Team Mangalorean
MANGALORE, February 15, 2010: The National Highway Mangalore division is in a fix, it can’t find contractors to repair the NH 48 stretch in the Shirady ghat. Contractors who have carried out the repair and relaying work on this stretch are unsure of giving warranty to the longevity of the road. They want the government to control the overloading of trucks that carry iron and manganese fines to the New Mangalore Port.
The Shirady ghat section was closed for traffic in October 2007 following the complete erosion of the road due to heavy movement of overloaded trucks.
Speaking to Mangalorean.com one of the contractors who carried out a part of the work on the stretch last time Ramesh Kumar Kottari told that he and two other contractors were ready to give warranty to the road provided the government adheres to the recommendations of the Indian Road Congress on over loading. “According to the recommendations a truck with 6 wheels can carry up to 10 tonnes and truck with 10 wheels can carry up to 16 tonnes. But the Transport authorities were allowing them to carry 40 tonnes”.

“Overloading is a universal problem; all roads in the state were being eroded due to the overloading. The only way it could be stopped was by strictly enforcing the loading discipline. The PWD has issued circulars to all the deputy commissioners of all the districts in the state to adopt zero tolerance stands towards overloading” says an official at NH Mangalore.
A paper by Balabhaskara Reddy, senior structural engineer, and A.Veeraraghavan of Bangalore University, which has been entitled "Effects of overloading and introduction of tandem-axle trucks on pavement life", highlights the structural damage to a pavement system caused by overloaded commercial vehicles.
The paper says overloading of trucks has assumed menacing proportions in the country. The structural adequacy of the pavement on National Highways is inadequate to withstand the increased magnitude of axle loads. The multi-axle vehicles reduce the impact of motion on the road and distribute the weight of the vehicle and the load evenly.
Executive Engineer of State National Highways S. Gopal says to minimise the intensity of damage, the National Highways, has recommended to the Government that weighbridges be constructed along the highways to bind the operators to conform to the rules and Registered Laden Weight (RLW) norms. The life of the roads with three layers of metal is three to five years depending on the volume of traffic. The lifespan is calculated on the basis of 10,000 passenger car units (PCU). One bus is equated to eight PCUs. The thickness of the road is determined on the basis of the California bearing ratio which is based on the potential load-carrying capacity.
The National Highways reports show that the percentage of vehicles moving on National Highway 48 with single rear axles (exceeding the prescribed 10.2 tonnes of load) was 55.3. Tandem-axle vehicles exceeding the prescribed 18 tonnes form 42.9 percent. The last review of the situation was made in 2003 which showed that the percentage would increase at 2.5 per cent a year.
The excessive wear and tear of National Highways, particularly at the curves, has been attributed to single-axle overloaded trucks.
| |
|
|
|
| JAYA, India |
Feb 20, 2010 |
BJP GOVT MUST GIVE CONTRACT TO MINING LORDS - REDDY BROTHERS OF BELLARY. THEY WILL DEMOLISH SHIRADI AND CHARMADI GHAT IN SEARCH OF IRON ORE, AND MAKE IT GHAT FREE!
THAT WAY THE ROADS WILL BE PROBLEM FREE BECAUSE THERE WILL BE NO GHAT!
VOTE FOR REDDY BROS! |
|
| Suraj, India |
Feb 19, 2010 |
| Extreme radical thought!, stop lorries with excess weight, burn them down. Kepp doing it till insureres refuse to insure the lorries. Keep doing it till lorry owners loose sleep. Keep doing it till you ar chased by the corrupt officials, politicians & cops. Because all are involved. And when they get close to you burn them too...well this can come true only in our masala movies!!! |
|
| Shetty, USA |
Feb 17, 2010 |
| If private companies cannot do the job the govt should give the job to the Indian Army. That would give the road life. Maybe convert it into toll road for better maintanence. |
|
| hylon rodrigues, India |
Feb 17, 2010 |
| the old contractors kothari consructions, bhandarkars construction from belthangady & other contractor have been blacklisted by the CBI for executing a substandard job last year & case is pending in the high court. these contractors have obtained a stay from the supreme court against their legal proceedings. being a regular travel in that ghat session, i have seen aspalting bitumen on the road on rainy days. now again they want to award the same work to them. this a height of corruption!! |
|
| V. Mallya, USA |
Feb 16, 2010 |
This should not be surprising - this fraud has been built many times over during the last 40-50 years. Now probably it is underfunded, has higher road standards, and needs significant amount in bribes. So, no contractor wants to bid! It is time to put this out for international bids and have a western company build roads that can last for 30-40 years. Alternatively, get the Indian Army Corps of Engineers to build this road.
If such roads can be and have been built in western countries, there is no reason why the government should not spend more and once for all fix this problem. Despite extremely cold temperatures, heavy rains, erosion etc., today there is adequate technology in the west to address these issues. It is such a pleasure to drive on these highways - some of which are are steeper and have sharper bends than Shiradi ghat. Yet, one does not see this nonsense like in the picture above.
It is the corruption in India that cannot be addressed and until it is addressed, this road and other roads will be built many times over and the tax payer will not even worry about this! |
|
| Sequeira Roshan, UAE |
Feb 15, 2010 |
Dear Mr Anil Pune,
Whatever the load it must distribute equly through the wheels of the vehicale,
for example if a vehicale carries 50 tons and only 4 wheels each of its will transfer a point load of 12.5 tons
If it has 6 wheels, each will transfer 8.5 tons and if it has 8 it will disribute 6.25 ton
So it is a noraml practice to limit the vehicle load to regulate the load transfer to the road all over the world.
A Mitusbishi Canter truck is designed to take 3tons of load, but its usally used to carry between 4 to 5 tons of load ( 100bags of cement , which is 5 ton) Who is the losser , tax payer, |
|
| pramod, USA |
Feb 15, 2010 |
| What does this mean? In USA, we have 18 wheelers hauling more than 40 tonnes and the roads are good. We they need to built concrete roads with good foundation atleat in the ghat section |
|
| Anil Pune, India |
Feb 15, 2010 |
Is that not possible to design roads to withstand 50 Tonnes of load, aren't there road exist in the entire world taking this much of load capacity ?
Dear Government and Contractors Think Big Act smart...
Don't blame on Rain and Don't blame on Transport system. If trucks don't ply on the roads you construct, are they meant to fly.? |
|
| Original R.Pai, USA |
Feb 15, 2010 |
| Probably Nilekani should take a look at this so-called 'National Highway' before assuming that everyone has roads similar to NICE or Blore-Chennai highway. |
|
| Max & Jessie Rasquinha, USA |
Feb 15, 2010 |
We have a dream that one day the Shiradi Ghadi and the Charmadi Ghadi will be some of the best scenic journeys of Karnataka. But that dream can only come true if we have a decent and safe road to travel without being frightened with deep pot holes and hazardous travel conditions. We have a dream that one day we shall invite many of our American and Canadian friends to visit our home as well as our farm, but without the safe and suitable roads this dream will not come true. The roads are so dangerous that our backs will start paining and our hearts will have fast beats.
India has such fine road contractors, and the Govt has such fine researchers, something has to be done to restore our roads at Shiradi Ghadi and Charmadi Ghadi so that we can visit India more often than ever before. |
|
|
|
|
|