Sign-In:  
New Member: Harshavardhan Devadiga, India | Join Now! |
Sep, 02
 

Mangalore: Don't wait till the marauders reach your door step- Margaret Alva


 

By Team Mangalorean, Mangalore

MANGALORE, September 19, 2008: "This time around when the city of Mangalore known as the Rome of the East felt the real heat of growing communal unrest," said general secretary of Congress party and one of the last fire brand leaders of the party Margaret Alva who was here to warn the community. Quoting the 19th century priest  Paster Martin Niemoller Mrs Alva said "When the Nazis came for the communists I remained silent…when they came for the Jews I remained silent…when they came for me there was no one left to speak out," She said this with an emotional note and should the history repeat itself no one will have anybody to blame for except themselves in India she said.

In a meeting with the Christian leaders in Mangalore at the Fr. Mullers Charitable Institutions in Kankanady Mrs. Alva told a gathering that Christians were nothing but a speck in the mass of humanity in Indian population. “We must not strike our differences this point of time but to put them aside and work in united combination to defeat the communal forces” She indicated to the leaders in the Christian community that there should be no barrage between the various sects of Christianity but all the sects of Christianity should come together to put down the communal forces. This was the second time in the history of the world we have seen fascist forces come to the fore she said. She said she had failed to understand why the Catholics allowed the Vishwa Hindu Parishat to set guidelines for a peace process.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

She said we are not bound to negotiate with a fundamentalist group which was fit for being banned. She took serious exception to the committee that has been formed between the VHP and the Catholic Diocese without the protestant Church and the members of the other sects. She told the Bishop of Mangalore Catholic diocese Dr. Aloysius Paul D'Souza that the truce was not acceptable to her.

Earlier addressing a press conference Mrs. Alva sasid accused the state government of trying to shield the Bajrang Dal which has claimed responsibility for attacking Christian prayer halls in the State.

Addressing the media while on a visit to the desecrated Adoration Monastery in Milagres Ms. Alva said, despite the Bajrang Dal claiming the responsibility of attacks on the Churches the home ministry of Karnataka had not done anything to arrest the leaders of Bajrang Dal which clearly indicated that the government was working hand in glove with the fundamentalist forces. “We have a fundamentalist government in the state” she added.

 She said she had no hesitation to state that the attacks on Churches were a part of a part of the larger design to implant fundamentalist hindutva agenda in the state. She demanded that the Chief Minister B.S. Yeddyurappa show enough courage and commitment to ban the Bajrang Dal and arrest its leaders.

Later speaking to the Mangalorean.com Mrs. Alva said I firmly believe that this was not the right occasion for politicizing the issue but to peep into ourselves as to see what kind of political culture or social order we are trying to bring in this society.  Mrs. Alva as immaculate and articulate in her thought and speech did not agree with the Catholic Church for leaving out the Protestant church.

Mrs. Alva also stated that like in Gujarat the police have been roped in to the organizational cadres of Bajrang Dal and VHP and their political mentor BJP.  "When the police become partisan the hope for civil society is lost," she added.

Taking objections to the lathi charge and tear gas lobbing at the peaceful protestors Mrs. Alva said she did not agree that the district administration should have resorted to the coercive methods.

Complete coverage:

Arrested catholic youths released from jail

Retired judge to probe K'taka Church attacks

Siddu, Moily, Poojary blasts Government

Catholics and Hindu organizations forge nexus

Mangalore: 'Attack on Churches is state sponsored rowdism' says Deve Gowda

Attack on churches: Govt orders CoD probe

Mangalore: Home minister assures fairplay

Udupi: No case of forcible conversion- Qureshi

Why we didn't turn the other cheek!

Violence against Christians: Women demand action against Police

Mahesh Bhatt asks Governor to send report to President, PM

State Government to spend on damage repair- Yeddyurappa

Violence against Christian continues: Bishop breaks his silence

Churches under attack: Sangh Parivar has successfully done it!

Attack on Churches: Police Lathi Charge and Tear Gas the Crowd!

Protest from across the world:

Kuwait: Prayer Meeting for Peace held

Chicago Christians call for Peace Rally

Doha: MCA condemns attack on Churches

Mangalorean Catholics in Muscat condemn violence in Mangalore

Violence in M'lore: Indian Christian community in Canada calls for protest

Indian Catholics in Kuwait condemn violence against Christians in Mangalore

Related News

Udupi: No case of forcible conversion- Qureshi

Nuns who shunned contact with the outside world feel terrorised

Bangalore: Ban New Life, Pentecost demands BJP

Advani danger to the country says Gowda

Mangalore: Statue desecration in Bejai hurt many

Christians are a worried lot in Chikmagalur

I know nothing of Bajrang Dal claim: Palemar

Udupi: Book the culprits first - Congress leaders

Christians under attack in India, toll 24

Church attacked in Kasargod district in Kerala

 Comment on this article Print this articlePrint article |  Send this article to a friend E-mail article
Name: Country:
Comments:
Security code: Security code   Reload Image
Enter code:   (shown above)
 
Kumar K, India Sep 23, 2008
It is really sad to see that some one vandalize the prayer place of another. Religion should be personal matter in a secular country. However, politicians have played caste and religion cards and always interested in divide and rule.
Vera Alvares, India Sep 21, 2008
Margaret Alva is shedding crocodile tears... she has been dispatched to ensure that the catholic votebank from Mangalore remains with the Congress.... has she followed her empty promises with action? More attacks in Bangalore are being reported and the Congress at the Center is fiddling while Karnataka is burning? What is the UPA waiting for...more atrocities? Why is article 356 not applied when the proof that the State government has failed to protect Minorities, is glaring in the face? Political mileage like everyone else...Congress is no better.
Pravin Rai, India Sep 20, 2008
Margret Alva, by the first look at you, I get pissed off. You too have come down like other ministers for political mileage. Look at your constituency, Delhi is burning and breeding with terrorist. We keep loosing our good police officer and good soldiers fighting because of you congress mess up. Also speak about delhi bombing and the upcoming terrorist plan. You congress should be thankful to Gujarat intelligence for the tip off but your dear madam pet shivraj patil keeps changing clothes and pass kiddy statement. Ofcourse what do you expect from an ordinary clerk during Indira Gangdhi rule. Alva please take a walk to delhi and see how it is burning.
Reshma Fonteiro, Israel Sep 20, 2008
Where were these Catholic "Pudaris" (petty politicians) now prominently basking in Mrs. Alva's and other Politicians’ presence when the other Catholics were demonstrating on the roads and getting beaten brutally by the police? How come none of these "Petty Pudaris" was arrested and sent to the far away jails such as Madikeri?

Where were the current and past Catholic corporators (how many of them in all)? They want the spotlight now !!! I curse these political goons that belong to the same colors and feathers no matter what political party they represent (depending on what is in for them in those parties).

Also, where were our other prominent Catholic social leaders such as the famous doctors, lawyers, engineers, builders, Konkani writers, contractors and other so called 'intellectuals"? They turned out to be pseudo intellectuals for whom their vested interests became more important than their community and religion/ Shame on them all. Most of them were not to be seen on any demonstrations or were beaten and arrested by the nazi goon squad (the DK police).
Joseph Kiran, India Sep 20, 2008
"When the Nazis came for the communists I remained silent…when they came for the Jews I remained silent…when they came for me there was no one left to speak out" Looks like Margaret Alva has done her homework pretty well. Now the only person left is One & Only Sonia. Please join the bandwagon and please finish your talks. We are fedup with these cheap politics. Its become a fashion to talk against Hindus.
Shaun, India Sep 20, 2008
Bert Naik & Shenoy,

If the ruling party BJP has FAILED to condemn and take appropriate action against these attacks then the buck passes on to the opposition. At least they have had the decency to come out and protest ......We DO NOT CARE EVEN IF ITS A POLTICAL GIMMICK. when Mangalore was burning Mr. L.K Advani (The product of a Covent School in Karachi, PAKISTAN) was in Bangalore and was 'silent as a mouse'......Even till date no word from him.

And if you are upset beacuse Margaret Alva has spoken the truth....then my friend "TRUTH IS BITTER".

M.Hussain, Qatar Sep 20, 2008
"When the Nazis came for the communists I remained silent…when they came for the Jews I remained silent…when they came for me there was no one left to speak out,"…………Margaret Alva

Atrocities, barbarism, unlawful police firing on mobs- peasants, suppression on poor, ousting people from their home, brutal killing, mass murder, planned murders, racial suppressions by any group or govt., or covertly actions by govt. are crime against humanity.

If such criminal actions are being taking place any part of the world people should oppose & forcibly stop it. Failing to which we or our future generation will be victim of the same acts.
SUNITHA PINTO, UAE Sep 20, 2008
It is rightly said by Mrs. Alva, excluding Protestsnt and other Denominations (New Life, Pentecost etc etc..) it was wrong step taken by the Catholic church to go for the peace talks. We are all christians following Christ in different ways, o why to differenciate now?
suhail khan, India Sep 20, 2008
This is what i expect of a true Indian, we need more Catholic who think like her, who work like her.
jacintha, India Sep 20, 2008
No truce at all, it is a cover up as the administration wanted it, for all we know, the priests might have been pressurised, kind people that they are, they do not see the game behind this. The fabric of friendship and trust is torn to pieces and each one of us knows it. All christian groups, irrespective of sects, have equal love for their religion and all should be given representation.
Simon Lasrado, India Sep 20, 2008
Mrs. Alva, a true daughter of konkani cathiolics, why cant you pressurize Mrs. Gandhi to dismiss this goonda govt.?
Mohan Menezes, India Sep 19, 2008
Margaret Alva is a courageous woman. She has spoken the truth. Despite being a Catholic she has the courage to tell the truce is not acceptable to her. This is because of the simple fact that our Protestant brothers were all left out simply because they do not have enough lobby. How can there be truce without involving all the parties?

Had the Bajrang Dal left the Adoration monastery out of attack I think there wouldnt have been any news at all in the first place and life would have been normal with just a small space in the corner of the newspaper for the news. Attacking a Catholic institution proved too costly for them.
Bert Naik, Australia Sep 19, 2008
This is absolutely worthless noise. This politician is more concerned about the Congress party's fortunes in Karnataka than worrying about the problems in Mangalore.
Rajanikanth Shenoy, Kudpi, India Sep 19, 2008
With Margaret Alva giving finishing touches to the Congress Bandwagon visiting and solacing our Catholic friends, may we except Congress to sweep the bye-election in Karnataka and the forthcoming Lok Sabha Election Shenoy Maam?
AHMED MANGALORE, UAE Sep 19, 2008
Mrs. Alva
Is the daughter of India.
And future Mother of India.
We have to join together and rule out their dreams.
Arun Menezes, India Sep 19, 2008
I fully agree with Mrs.Alva, all the Christians(All sects) should unite and fight the communal forces, we should not let the other down, but we should all stand as one,no one is guilty unless proven otherwise, so unless it is proved that the New Life group has forcably converted anyone, we should not oppose them........the BJP,BD and VHP are trying to divide the Christian population. I agree that the Bishop should have consulted all the sects(Protestents....etc) of christianity before taking any decission on peace agreement.
 
 
Web Mangalorean.Com
 
Privacy  |  Terms and Conditions  |  Tell your Friend  |  Contact Us  |  Join Us  |  Home    
Site designed and maintained by Mangalorean Media LLC.