Bengaluru: After a string of writs, counter-petitions, objections and stay orders, the case of sexual assault against Shri Raghaveshwara Bharati of Hosanagara Math is set for further delays.
Two judges of the state high court, Justices Phaneendra and Ramamohan Reddy had recused themselves at two different stages. When the case came up for hearing on Monday, Jan 10, Justice N Kumar too announced his decision to withdraw from the bench.
When the question of medical examination of the Swamiji had come up in November last, Justice Phaneendra had recused himself, leaving Justice Venugopal Gowda to deliver the interim verdict.
Monday saw the case come up before the special division bench consisting of Justices N Kumar and B Veerappa. Justice Kumar announced his decision to withdraw, with an appeal that the case be transferred to any bench that he was no a part of. He instructed the registrar general of the court to pass on the files to the Chief Justice.
Interestingly, as in the earlier two cases, he has not cited any reason for his action. A retired judge of the supreme court, when asked for his opinion, said that having taken an oath of dispensation of justice without fear or favour, a judge was duty-bound to hear both sides and dispose of the case. That being his responsibility, in the event of a conflict of interests, it was advisable to bring it in the open, he said. Such instances have taken place in the past, he reminded.
Former Karnataka Lokayukta Justice Santosh Hegde feels that a judge need not offer any reason for backing out. Since it is a sensitive issue, the three honourable judges have stepped aside so that no suspicions or misgivings would arise in the future. Hence it was a correct move, he says.
Case history:
- Bengaluru: Rape-accused Swamiji’s DNA Test Positive: Advocate General
- Bengaluru: Raghaveshwara Case – HC Orders Shastri Couple be Made Respondents
- Bengaluru: Sexual Assault Case – Swamiji Undergoes Medical Tests, Declines Three
- Bengaluru: Setback for Swamiji as High Court Okays Medical Test
- Bengaluru: Swamiji Granted Conditional Bail in Sexual Assault Case
- Bengaluru: Sexual Assault Case – Havyaka Forum Wants Swamiji to Voluntarily Undergo Tests
- Bengaluru: Swamiji Case: CID Questions RSS Leader Kalladka Prabhakar Bhat
-
B
engaluru: Two Arrested for Slandering Shastri Couple’s Daughter in Facebook
- Bengaluru: New Twist to Singer Vs Swamiji Case with Reported Entry of Underworld Don
- New Delhi: Sexual Assault Charges against Swamiji – Women’s Commission Steps in
- Puttur: Demand for a Comprehensive Probe into Kedila Shastri Suicide Case Snowballs
- Honnavar: Amid High Drama Police Notice Issued to Raghaveshwara Bharati Swamiji
- Honnavar: Alleged Blackmail Attempt on Math’s Artistes – Shastri Couple Gets Conditional Bail
- Puttur: CID Team Arrives in Town to Probe Kedila Shyam Prasad Shastri’s Suicide
- Puttur: Case of Shastri Suicide in Kedila also Likely to be Probed by CID
- Puttur: Kedila Residents Demand Thorough Probe into Shastri’s Alleged Suicide
- Puttur: Urimajalu Ram Bhat Appeals to Havyaka Community to Maintain Restraint
- Mangalore: Threat Calls Led Shastry to End Life, Says Wife in Complaint to Police
- Mangalore: Shyam Prasad Shastry from Kedila who Shot Himself Dies in Hospital